How much compensation you get for a shoulder impingement settlement amount in Florida varies based on the unique circumstances of each situation and the severity of your injuries. Based on our own settlement data on this page, the average settlement for shoulder impingement is between $150,000 to $1,000,000.

Average Settlement for Shoulder Impingement Case Examples

$1,000,000 for Shoulder Impingement Settlement – 2025

On March 14, 2023, our client was driving west on State Road 70 in Manatee County, Florida, when the unexpected happened. A driver waiting at a stop sign on 1st Street pulled out without warning, forcing our client to swerve. Despite her efforts, her car collided with the other vehicle and flipped onto its roof. Emergency responders had to cut her out of the car, and she was rushed to the hospital.

At the hospital, our client was diagnosed with upper and lower back injuries, post-concussion syndrome, and significant shoulder damage, including a severe shoulder impingement injury. As the pain persisted, she began working with a pain management specialist. MRIs of her neck, back, left shoulder, and left knee revealed extensive damage, leading to multiple injections and ongoing treatment.

When her back pain didn’t improve, a neurosurgeon recommended surgery. She first underwent an anterior cervical discectomy and fusion, but the pain returned quickly, requiring a follow-up posterior cervical discectomy and fusion. Throughout this process, the injuries, including her shoulder impingement, continued to limit her daily activities and caused ongoing discomfort.

After recovery, our team pursued compensation from the defendant’s insurance carrier, who initially tried to offer far less than the $1,000,000 bodily injury policy limits. We pressed the insurer, and once they realized litigation was imminent, they agreed to pay the full policy limits. This settlement allowed our client to cover her medical bills, ongoing therapy, and begin rebuilding her life after a serious accident and debilitating shoulder impingement injury.

$150,000 Shoulder Impingement Settlement Amount – 2023

On July 19, 2022, our 34-year-old client, who worked for an excavation company, was driving south on Tamiami Trail when another driver negligently turned directly into his path, causing a collision. The other driver was cited by police for improperly changing lanes and pulling out in front of our client.

Soon after the accident, our client began experiencing pain in his neck and right shoulder. He sought treatment at a nearby clinic, and after therapy, an MRI revealed inflammation, bursitis, and a possible tendon tear in his shoulder. Due to ongoing pain, he was referred to an orthopedic surgeon, who recommended arthroscopic surgery to relieve the shoulder impingement injury. The surgery was successful and helped alleviate his pain.

We then prepared a detailed demand package seeking compensation from the defendant’s insurance company. The insurer initially argued that the side-impact collision could not have caused a shoulder injury. We countered by highlighting our client’s lack of prior shoulder issues and that his pain started immediately after the accident. After negotiations, the insurer agreed to pay $150,000, a settlement that reflected the severity of his shoulder impingement injury and left our client very satisfied with the outcome.

What You Can Expect From a Typical Shoulder Impingement Settlement Amounts

A shoulder impingement occurs when the tendons or soft tissue in the shoulder become compressed or irritated during movement. This often happens when the space between the shoulder bones narrows, causing pain, inflammation, and limited range of motion. Symptoms may worsen with overhead activity and can progress over time, sometimes leading to tendon damage or the need for surgical treatment if conservative care does not resolve the condition.

Many shoulder impingement claims also arise in the workplace, and in workers’ compensation cases, settlement amounts are often influenced by medical costs, time away from work, and whether the injury causes permanent work restrictions.

General Shoulder Impingement Settlement Ranges

In addition to individual case results, shoulder impingement settlements generally fall within a range based on the severity of the injury, the type of treatment required, and how the injury affects daily life and work.

While every case is different, many shoulder impingement and related shoulder injury claims tend to settle within the following general ranges.

Minor, Non-Surgical Shoulder Impingement

These cases often resolve with physical therapy, rest, or injections. Settlements commonly fall between $5,000 and $50,000, depending on pain levels, recovery time, and disruption to normal activities.

Moderate Shoulder Impingement Without Surgery

Cases involving prolonged treatment, repeated therapy, or ongoing symptoms often settle in the $30,000 to $150,000 range.

Shoulder Impingement Requiring Surgery, Including Arthroscopic Procedures

Surgical cases usually result in higher settlement values due to increased medical expenses, longer recovery periods, and the possibility of lasting limitations. These claims often range from $150,000 to $300,000 or more.

Severe Or High Impact Cases

When shoulder impingement leads to permanent impairment, reduced earning capacity, or significant lifestyle changes, settlements can exceed typical ranges. In some cases, outcomes may reach $150,000 to $1,000,000 or more, depending on the specific facts.

These figures reflect common settlement patterns and are not guaranteed outcomes.

Key Factors That Affect Shoulder Impingement Settlement Amounts

Medical treatment required – Cases involving only conservative care tend to settle for less, while those requiring surgery often result in higher settlement amounts due to increased costs and longer recovery.

Severity of the injury – Temporary inflammation or mild impingement generally results in lower settlements than injuries involving chronic pain, limited range of motion, tendon damage, or permanent limitations.

Impact on work and daily life – Settlement values often increase when the injury interferes with job duties, restricts physical activity, or affects future earning potential.

Medical documentation and consistency of care – Clear medical records and consistent treatment support stronger settlement demands. Gaps in treatment or incomplete documentation can reduce case value.

Putting Settlement Ranges Into Context

Settlement amounts are not determined by diagnosis alone. Two people with shoulder impingement may receive very different outcomes depending on how the injury affects their health, finances, and long-term recovery.

For example, a person who recovers quickly with physical therapy may resolve their claim near the lower end of the range. Someone who requires surgery, extended rehabilitation, or experiences ongoing shoulder problems may fall toward the higher end based on long-term impact.

Every shoulder impingement case is unique. Settlement ranges reflect general patterns based on past outcomes and should not be viewed as guarantees. Insurance coverage, liability, medical evidence, and individual circumstances all influence the final result.

Contact Us for Help With Your Shoulder Impingement Settlement

If you or a loved one has suffered a shoulder injury in an accident, don’t navigate the insurance process alone. At Abrahamson & Uiterwyk, our legal team understands how a shoulder impingement can affect daily life and long-term mobility, and we fight to secure the full compensation our clients deserve. Contact us today to speak with a Clearwater personal injury lawyer about your shoulder impingement settlement options.

Related Articles: