Our clients deserve the best representation we can offer as we work to gain favorable personal injury settlements in each case we take on. Our track record can be seen in the settlements we obtain for each and every client and their family.

We are here to help. Our team of aggressive personal injury lawyers near you in Florida are here to fight for you on a contingency fee basis. No fee unless we win. If you need assistance obtaining a settlement after an accident, please review our settlement examples below – all taken from our case files over the years.

As always, if you have questions and want to speak to a personal injury attorney, please don’t hesitate to contact us at 800-538-4878 today for a same-day response and transparent communication about your claim.

Personal Injury Settlement Payouts in Florida

How much compensation you get for a personal injury settlement in Florida varies based on the unique circumstances of each situation and the severity of your injuries. Based on our own settlement data on this page, the average personal injury settlement is between $100,000 to $1,600,000.

1.6 Million Dollar Personal Injury Settlement Payout – Car Accident

A client was riding in the back seat of a car when another driver made an illegal left turn and failed to yield the right of way to oncoming traffic. The two vehicles collided head-on.

The impact was severe. The passenger was airlifted to the hospital and treated for serious injuries, including a broken pelvis, a broken leg, a neck fracture, neck pain, and a closed head injury that caused bleeding in the brain. The injuries required surgeries to repair the pelvis and leg, along with ongoing treatment and rehabilitation for the brain injury.

A demand was sent to the at-fault driver’s insurance company, but their first offer was $300,000, which was rejected. A lawsuit was then filed.

During the case, depositions were taken from the driver, witnesses, and the treating doctors. The injured passenger also underwent evaluations by doctors hired by the insurance company, one of whom confirmed that the brain injury was permanent.

The insurance company later increased its offer to $500,000, and then to $750,000 during mediation, but both offers were rejected.

As the case moved closer to trial and continued through litigation, the parties ultimately reached a settlement of $1.6 million.

$200,000 Personal Injury Case Settlement – DUI Accident

A 39-year-old advertising account executive was out with her husband and friends on Treasure Island, Florida, in June 2021. The group was traveling in a street-legal golf cart, heading from one restaurant to another across the street. She was seated in the rear-facing back seat when the driver suddenly made a hard and unexpected U-turn, causing her to be thrown from the cart onto the pavement.

She was taken to a nearby hospital with injuries to her head, face, and left hand. She suffered cuts around her right eye and on her hand that required stitches. In the weeks that followed, she underwent treatment with specialists, including a nerve repair surgery on her hand performed by an orthopedic surgeon. She also required extensive dental work after two teeth were fractured in the accident. In addition, her plastic surgeon determined that she would need future surgery to revise facial scarring caused by the crash.

The driver carried a $100,000 bodily injury insurance policy, but the insurance company initially denied responsibility and argued that their insured had not been negligent in operating the golf cart. Their first settlement offer was only $34,000.

The law firm repeatedly presented evidence showing that the driver’s sudden maneuver directly caused the injuries and documented the full extent of the client’s damages. They made clear that they would not accept anything less than the full policy limits. Eventually, facing the likelihood of litigation, the insurance company agreed to pay the full $100,000 policy limit to resolve the claim.

The client also carried $100,000 in uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage through her own insurance policy. A separate demand package was submitted showing that her damages exceeded the at-fault driver’s coverage limits. After further negotiations, her insurance company agreed to pay an additional $100,000.

In total, the case resolved for $200,000.

$100,000 Personal Injury Settlement Payout – Pedestrian Accident 2025

A 17-year-old pedestrian was walking with a friend along the far-right side of Jaslo Avenue in North Port, Florida, on the evening of February 3, 2025. It was dark outside, and the two teenagers were traveling eastbound when a driver approached from behind in the same direction.

The driver failed to notice the pedestrians on the side of the road and struck the teenager with the passenger-side mirror of the vehicle, knocking him to the ground.

After the impact, the teen immediately experienced severe pain in his right foot. Paramedics arrived at the scene and transported him to the hospital for treatment. X-rays later revealed a physeal fracture of the second metatarsal in his right foot, which is an injury involving the growth plate of one of the long bones in the foot. He was placed in a short leg splint and instructed not to put weight on the injured foot while it healed.

Although the fracture eventually healed over time, the injury left him with a slight deformity in one of his toes.

A demand package was submitted to the at-fault driver’s insurance company, GEICO, which carried a $100,000 bodily injury policy. The demand gave the insurer a limited amount of time to pay the full policy limits. Given the clear liability of the driver and the seriousness of the injury, GEICO chose to tender the full $100,000 policy rather than face a lawsuit and potential trial.

The case ultimately resolved for the full $100,000 policy limits.

Florida Personal Injury Settlement Amount Examples

Examples of Personal Injury Settlements in Florida:

Slip & Fall Case Settlement Amounts in Florida

personal injury settlements

Other Accident Type Settlements in Florida

personal injury settlements

Florida Insurance Company Settlement Case Amounts

personal injury settlements

Florida Personal Injury & Bodily Injury Settlement Examples

Other Florida Personal Injury Settlement Resources

FAQs About Settlement Agreements in Florida

While we’ve all seen and heard about dramatic trials and jury verdicts, the truth is that most personal injury cases end in a settlement agreement before trial. Mediation in personal injury settlements is a common way to reach these agreements, providing an alternative to the uncertainty of a courtroom verdict.

While the facts surrounding settlement agreements are case-specific, there are some questions our dedicated and compassionate personal injury lawyers can help answer when it comes to settlements.

If you’re wondering how long it will take to receive your GEICO settlement check after an agreement is reached, how will a car accident settlement affect my SSDI benefits, or about spinal fusion car accident settlements, read more in these articles.

What is a Settlement Agreement?

A settlement agreement is a formal agreement between you and the other party that you will drop your lawsuit, or decline to pursue a lawsuit, in exchange for a certain amount of money. This typically happens after a lawsuit has been filed and each side has the opportunity to see the strengths and weaknesses of each other’s case through the discovery process, which may include depositions and review of evidence and documentation such as medical records and police reports.

Do I Have to Accept a Settlement Agreement?

Settlement agreements are based on the premise that both parties agree before it takes effect. While your attorney may recommend that you agree to a settlement, the decision is ultimately yours to make. Understanding what to expect during the settlement negotiation process can help you make an informed decision about whether to accept or counter a settlement offer.

Why Should I Settle My Claim?

When presenting you with a settlement agreement, your attorney will discuss with you the specific reasons why it may be advantageous to settle your claim. No matter what the facts and legal issues are in a case, putting the decision in front of a jury can be a gamble. There are no guarantees, and sometimes it can make more sense to take the safe road instead of taking a risk and trusting a jury with your case. A fair and reasonable settlement can provide you with substantial compensation without the uncertainty and delays of litigation or appeal.

Why Would the Other Party Want to Settle a Case?

Fear of uncertainty can also make an opposing party willing to settle a case. If it is financially better for them to settle rather than take their chances at trial, then they will do so. This is where having an attorney on your side can be very helpful. An experienced attorney can show an opposing party how strong your case is and why you may win at trial. Our attorneys investigate accidents thoroughly, gather evidence, and prove case strength to maximize settlements and protect client rights. This would encourage the opposing side to agree to sit down and negotiate a settlement.

Call Us to Discuss Your Florida Car Accident Injury

If you’ve been injured in a Florida car accident, you owe it to yourself to find excellent legal representation near you. We’ve helped thousands of clients recover hundreds of millions of dollars over the past 35 Years. Our proven and successful team of board-certified attorneys works on a no-upfront-cost basis, offering home visits, hospital visits, and virtual consultations for your convenience.

We can’t represent everyone, but we help everyone we can. Call us for a FREE consultation. We’ll conduct a comprehensive investigation and provide a detailed case analysis to establish negligence and calculate damages accurately. We’ll review your case and let you know if we can give you the legal representation you deserve.

Injured in Valrico? Contact us to speak to a personal injury lawyer in Valrico today!

What Our Happy Clients Say About Us on Google

This law firm is absolutely amazing. I had a slip and fall accident and decided to use Abrahamson and Uiterwyk after doing some research and reading their excellent reviews and their receiving the highest rating from the Better Business Bureau. Everyone is highly qualified and helpful through the process. From my initial phone call, to the resolution of my case, everyone was kind, helpful, patient, and responsive. I highly recommend them and I will call them in the future if the need ever arises. I am grateful for the settlement they were able to negotiate for me. Thank you Abrahamson and Uiterwyk!

On This Page show